Features

Gave it another honest chance.

23d agoClosed

So im a 2,200 hour veteran who stopped playing with the release of "maint" feeling the update was wildly untested and unbalanced and getting only " play by yourself if you wanna change settings" from dennis the unhelpful troll. i flat out quit the game for a Very long time. well i came back to give it an honest chance and...

the server i was on died. quite early. we had just unlocked lumber, but that was only because 2 people took on 16 jobs between them.

Maint: lets start with the obvious. things break too quickly. i mean WAY too quickly. 58 hours is what you get from a windmill before it needs to be entirely replaced. hilarious considering windmills still standing in abandoned fields turn with years of neglect. and tools "integrity" degrades so fast its insane. makes zero sense.' ohh did you sharpen your axe? thats like..20% of a tool you cant get back' most players use it till it breaks, and then make a new one. ( not entirely bad idea, but once again you shoe-horned this 'feature' to try and force players to use obsolete jobs beyond their usefulness. so its not implemented well at all. instead of a simulated wear and tear youve got things like the magical 58 hour windmill that make No sense.) and players wind up taking their windmill down when not in use to avoid the stupid tax. which is Super unrealistic.

Upgrades: upgrade modules are entirely ruined as a concept now. none of us even bothered to waste resources on them. 5% off? when you think an single iron shovel needs 12 bars and 8 pieces of leather? jfc (feels like you use high costs to try and shoe-horn players into repairing them more, but they still just make new. so now youve got unrealistic costs and an ignored repair system)

Towns: forming a town requires people to settle directly next to each other, which is counter to how anyone actually plays the game. we couldnt form a town before the population got so small it was impossible to form one. one of the reasons pop dropped so fast was farmers unable to claim fields, miners unable to claim mines, and industry having to be setup at their own homestead cause they couldnt claim anything else. so i didnt get to test any new govt features at all. (feels like towns were shoe-horned to force players together, but it didnt work)

Garbage: not.. entirely a bad idea. but in traditional eco fashion it was shoe-horned into the game to force players to behave a certain way. instead of implemented as a proper simulation that players should solve. why exactly can i not hand sort wood scrap from biowaste? why do i need industrial equipment to sort garbage at all? (because you wanted to force players to "deal" with garbage. but only in your very linear wildly unrealistic ways.) why doesnt making a landfill work? -_-

Information: the game has VERY poor information given on how it works, and because the player count is so low, the internet doesnt help. the only posts are 6+years old, because thats when people still played. Example. Tailings. the in game wiki says " dont bury them! it wont help anymore! they need to be properly contained!" what does that mean? who knows. there is ZERO further information on what "containment" might mean. and trying to google it gets you ancient posts that just say " bury them ofc" i was told by someone on server the new method is " put them on a mountain peak away from all water and people" but ofc you cant Claim a second property so you either live in the filth or leave it unclaimed and hope no one screws you by taking ladders or ramps away on a whim.

Food: spoilage was a bad idea. and continues to be a bad idea. once again not simulated its simply shoe-horned in to force farmers to keep farming, and a punish stockpiling food as it turns to pollution (when in reality its compost? lmfao? should be helping plants..) the problem lies in your misunderstanding of how fast things should spoil. the apple on my counter irl, been there 10 days. still crisp. the pineapple in your game? 24 hours its rotten.

And dennis, spare me the " you can adjust settings" no dennis. no i cant. because i dont play alone. and im not hosting the server. stop telling everyone the same thing when they RIGHTFULLY criticize the default eco experience. Balance your game. stop trying to force me to balance it for you.

2 comments

  1. very normal eco thing to do. button says "give feedback" not "give feedback ina certain format so we can vote on it"

    and dennis buddy, its not a personal attack. its a matter of fact. you. are an unhelpful troll who contantly tells anyone that criticies the default experience to "change settings" ive seen you do it a hundred time.

  2. Dennis Scholz marked this as Closed21d ago
  3. Thanks for your feedback. Unfortunately this tracker is intended for posting improvement and feature suggestions in a way that they can be voted on by players individually, allowing us to gauge interest in a specific change or feature. A whole list in a singular submission doesn't provide for that and hence forfeits the purpose of this tracker, so I'm closing this suggestion. I have instead provided it directly to the team for consideration, feedback in this form can also be sent to support@strangeloopgames.com and will be added to the general feedback we always collect from all channels.

    In regard to your remark about configurability - Eco is a game that can be played in singleplayer, in coop with a small group; alone or as a group on small servers with 30 players, medium servers with 70 players or a large server with 150 players or more and everything in-between. Players also have different interests (Building, Grinding, Ecology, Economy, Politics, etc.) as well as different amounts of time they can and want to spend and as such very different expectations. Eco as a game focused around how players cooperate (or not) tends to play very different depending on each of these factors and the organization level on any given server. It is hence impossible to provide defaults that work for anyone on any server no matter how that server runs or its players play - and Eco was never intended to do so, it was from the ground up developed as a framework where administrators can configure their servers fitting exactly their (desired) audiences. Doing so is not only recommendable, it is necessary for achieving the best possible experience for one's specific audience. For players that of course doesn't mean playing singleplayer as you seem to suggest, it means that looking for a server that fits ones individual playstyle and interests is a major factor in having the best possible experience and that every player will naturally consider something else to be that - be it slightly or majorly different. We for example provide a channel on our discord for purposes of finding a community that fits one's needs.

    It is perfectly understandable that you disagree with some of our design choices and / or default settings, but personal attacks against me or any other staff are not acceptable. Our defaults ultimately are only that - settings that have been chosen to fit a number of common approaches to servers assuming a minimum organization level, based on our design goals that for example include the usage of settlements (which in future updates are intended to be expanded to become more and more game-definining). That of course isn't everyone's "thing" and naturally means that they cannot cover every player's preferences - but that is also not their goal, nor can we provide an unlimited amount of presets for different experiences. Eco simply is not a streamlined experience mostly independant from outside factors. As a social simulation it also isn't supposed to be - even on servers with the same settings and audiences with roughly the same interests one can get vastly different experiences based on who is actually playing and that is intended. A game with a hundred other active players plays completely different and the necessity for food spoilage and maintenance to keep the economy going will be significantly more apparent there than it is on singleplayer, where it might feel needlessly restrictive and annoying - whereas on a medium sized server it can heavily depend on how market participants behave (or, depending on server rules and laws, are expected to behave). We can't forsee that - the administrators of a server however do have the necessary information.

    This tracker is however the perfectly right place if you want some default settings to change - they are supposed to fit some of the most common approaches and while we believe that they fulfill that purpose well, we'll happily make changes where that seems in order. Individual suggestions getting a significant amount of votes is one indicator for that - and for the last few updates it has also been one of our priorities to implement specifically such suggestions. That however would require you to repost each suggestion as an individual submission - it doesn't need to be long, just clearly focused on a single point and what improvement you want to see so that other players can vote on if they agree with that criticism or desired change or not, without necessarily needing to agree with a multitude of other points they might not.