What I would like to see is a resolution to Verticle Integration without actually removing it. Because if you truly want something like Mining, Smelting, Mechanics or Gathering, Farming, Hunting, Butchery, Cooking etc..
Then you should be able to, but with a catch... it should be much harder to achieve and how do we do this? By making it when you LEARN a skill all skills increase by 1 to 5 stars based on how closely they ingrate with each other.
NO INTEGRATION = 1 Star Increase
LOW INTEGRATION = 2 Star Increase
MEDIUM INTEGRATION = 3 Star Increase
HIGH INTREGRATION = 4 Star Increase
EXTREME INTEGRATION = 5 Star Increase
An example is as follows
**** YOU LEARN MINING **** Cost 1 Star
Smelting increases by 5
Masonry increases by 4
Adv Masonry increases by 4
Glassworking increases by 3
Everything else increases by 1.
**** YOU LEARN SMELTING **** COST 5 Stars + Base Cost
Mechanics increases by 5.
Adv Smelting increases by 4.
**** YOU LEARN Mechanics **** COST 6 Stars + Base Cost
Mechanics increases by 5.
Adv Smelting increases by 4.
I don't remember the "Base Costs" but basically you're looking at nearly 20 stars to learn these 3 skills. When you could have learned like Mining, Logging, Gathering in 6 Stars.
It doesn't have to be done with these numbers, but the idea is that learning a certain skills puts pressure on learning vertical integrated skills which in turn slow down these types of players from abusing the benefits of vertical integration when the rest of the server isn't pushing that direction themselves.
So you're allowed to do it, but you'd have to put in far more effort to achieve it then others who went non vertical aligned skills allowing them the ability to make better use of their skills sooner before you can do a whole chain of a skill for no cost on your end.